Mafia game 5 - GAME IS ON!

[Workdawg]

I almost voted for Nate with something like "Free wifi why didn't you say that sooner!?" ... then I saw he has 3 votes already

ROFL. Good thing you didn't... not everyone has chimed in on their "cases against people" as I asked.

Tom and Ben have been chatboxxing it up, and even posted after my request and haven't presented cases.

:yuno: give me case!

 

[concealer404]

ROFL. Good thing you didn't... not everyone has chimed in on their "cases against people" as I asked.

Tom and Ben have been chatboxxing it up, and even posted after my request and haven't presented cases.

:yuno: give me case!

I'm thinking.... and working. There's three people i'm deeply suspicious of. I need to eliminate one.

 

[Picklz]

Why not make your case for all 3 and let all the rest of us help? Not sharing information doesn't really help town at all.

 

[Workdawg]

If you can come up with cases against 3 people, then lets hear them all! Maybe you've thought of something the rest of us haven't.

 

[concealer404]

Ok i'll do so. Just hold your horses. Not like any of it is concrete anyways.

 

[mndsm]

ROFL. Good thing you didn't... not everyone has chimed in on their "cases against people" as I asked.

Tom and Ben have been chatboxxing it up, and even posted after my request and haven't presented cases.

:yuno: give me case!

Been slammed at work, hard to put more than a dick joke down between stuff. I'll get to it tonight.

 

[Picklz]

Vote: Ben

 

[Z-licious]

Current vote count (11/30 8:16 PM)

Picklz [0]
Dan [0]
Tom [0]
Nate [3] - Dan, Ben, Andy
Andy [1] - Josh
Josh [0]
Ben [2] - Nate, Picklz

Not Voting [1] - Tom

With 7 players alive, 4 votes are needed to lynch!

Deadline to vote: 10/31, 9pm.

24 hours left till deadline

 

[Workdawg]

Current vote count (11/30 8:16 PM)

This has been bothering me for the past few vote counts...

 

[mndsm]

Ben We all know my case history with Ben- He's close to the top, but he has been fading back in the pack lately. It seems that after the initial bullshit trolling, which is all you can really do until you can build a case, has lessened some. Still a little perturbed with the "trying too hard" bit.

Andy probably my top right now. The flip flop voting and flat out bandwagoning by his own admittance, is sketchy as fuck. The one thing that gets me about it is- who the hell admits that flat out as scum? the oddball thing with it is, he's playing about as flat out scum as humanly possible- which makes for the obvious vote. But, it's almost too obvious.... that's the odd thing.

I honestly don't really have a 3rd, but if I had to pick one i'd say Swanny No real specific reason, but I get the scum vibe.

 

[Picklz]

Even though he played the same way during Game 1 (very similar, anyway). Flat out calling that you're going to bandwagon vote is a bit puzzling.... VOTE: Andy - Can you explain why you did that? I still feel like Ben is a better vote at this point but I can't discount the oddity of this behavior.

 

[Workdawg]

How do you feel about Nate, Tom?

 

[Big Nate]

Final vote count

Picklz [0]
AJ [5] - Dan, Tom, AJ, Ben, JT
Dan [0]
Tom [0]
JT [0]
Nate [0]
Andy [0]
Josh [0]
Ben [0]

Not Voting [4] - Picklz, Nate, Andy, Josh

Current vote count (11/30 8:16 PM)

Picklz [0]
Dan [0]
Tom [0]
Nate [3] - Dan, Ben, Andy
Andy [1] - Josh
Josh [0]
Ben [2] - Nate, Picklz

Not Voting [1] - Tom

With 7 players alive, 4 votes are needed to lynch!

Deadline to vote: 10/31, 9pm.

24 hours left till deadline

Well I reread all the vote counts from past games. Every time both scum voted for the person who got lynched.
Now that means looking at this count we can narrow the pool down to Dan, Tom, AJ, Ben, JT.
AJ - voted himself out so he is not scum
JT - got snuffed out by scum
Now that leave only three.
Dan - is a very experienced player and know we are not as xp'd. I think he is scum and is hiding in plain site. He is advocating to have me lynched and I am not scum. Yes I have changed my play style a bit but only in the fact that I am not saying dumb shit all the time.
Ben - Is a savvy online person and understands how to play a game like this. He is playing in a way that would lead me to believe he is scum. My vote has been with him to try and see what others would do. But he is not at the top of my list to be scum.
Thom - Could be scum could be town. Like others have said he is playing differently then last game but then again so am I and i am not scum.

We that leads me to the current count. With Dan, Ben, Andy all voting for me.
Andy - Not sure seems to be try to scum hunt but get defensive when confronted.
Dan - Just more scum fear mongering trying to get others to rally behind him against me.
Ben - leads me to believe he is scum
Thom - Could have dropped the hammer and won the game for scum so he is off the list.

 

[WhiteSpy9]

I think you missed an unvote there sir.

Vote: Ben

Even though he played the same way during Game 1 (very similar, anyway). Flat out calling that you're going to bandwagon vote is a bit puzzling.... VOTE: Andy - Can you explain why you did that? I still feel like Ben is a better vote at this point but I can't discount the oddity of this behavior.

I changed my vote to Nate to provoke more discussion from him, just like you are doing to me.
Look at the last post from Nate!!! It is the largest, most helpful post, I have ever seen from him in any game. So I will say that joining the bandwagon to bring more focus to Nate, has worked.

UNVOTE: NATE

I clearly labelled it as a bandwagon vote, because I know that is how you all would perceive it, but that is how I play this game. I like to throw my vote around, when ever I want and however I want. This gives a bad vibe to some people, but for some reason when other people do it.... it goes practically un-noticed.

You should have all the pieces to put that puzzle now to put it all together.

 

[mndsm]

How do you feel about Nate, Tom?

Nate- a lot of what he's doing doesn't make sense. It kind of gives a scummy vibe, simply because he's not really offering himself up with answers and things like that.

 

[Workdawg]

All you had to do was post that 2 days ago and it wouldn't be suspicious. Now it just looks like you see that your hiding is about to be your downfall and you are trying to save yourself; IMO.

In response to your voting analysis... you are quite correct that last game both scum were on the wagons together. However you've missed (or left out) some important details.

Last game:
- D1: Everyone online at the end was on your wagon. It just so happens both scum (and not enough town, lol) were there to try and get a lynch done.
- D2: AJ is just kind of a dumbass followed Matt's posts a lot. Remember Josh's vote analysis from that game, go look at it. Almost all the time Picklz voted from someone, AJ followed up not long after. That's newbie scum play and if I were scum, I would have made damn sure my teammate wasn't following me around.
- D3: Town put themselves in a bad position and let Picklz hammer for the win.

This game:
- D1: I voted for AJ because he was genuinely scummy as shit. He even voted for himself, which actually makes it WAY easier for scum to avoid the wagon. I think it's likely there was at least one scum on AJ's wagon... but I wouldn't put much stock in both being there; especially considering that JT hammered a little bit early.
- D2: Votes have been going back and forth quite a bit. So this can't be an accurate measure. Ben has been at L-1 a couple of times as well and I haven't voted for him at all. It's been a combination of YOU, Picklz, Tom and Andy.

In response to the rest:

What actually makes me scum? You didn't actually post any reason to think I'm scum other than because I'm trying to get you lynched. Do you not think you were acting scummy previously? What justification do you have for trying to hide up until now and refusing to give your opinion. By now, you have to know that information is good for town, so why did you refuse to help?

Tom hammering you wouldn't win the game for scum. We are going to D3 no matter what. Further, even if he was scum, he probably wouldn't hammer early because it would look suspicious. Alternatively, maybe you are his scum buddy and he wants to buy time for you to talk your way out of it, or for another wagon to pull ahead.

 

[Workdawg]

And the last sentence makes for an interesting segue into my most recent theory. Team Beard... Nate and Tom.

Stay tuned for details.

 

[Z-licious]

Current vote count (10/31 8:52 AM)

Picklz [0]
Dan [0]
Tom [0]
Nate [2] - Dan, Ben
Andy [1] - Josh
Josh [0]
Ben [2] - Nate, Picklz

Not Voting [2] - Tom, Andy

With 7 players alive, 4 votes are needed to lynch!

Deadline to vote: 10/31, 9pm.

12 hours left till deadline

 

[Picklz]

I didn't realize we had to 'unvote' first....if so my bad...

UNVOTE: Andy

I'm going back to my original vote for now - Ben makes the most sense to me at this point, and he STILL hasn't shared his 'theories' as asked, I know he's going to come in with reasoning for not doing so, thus I'll leave it at that.

Vote: Ben

 

[concealer404]

I didn't realize we had to 'unvote' first....if so my bad...

UNVOTE: Andy

I'm going back to my original vote for now - Ben makes the most sense to me at this point, and he STILL hasn't shared his 'theories' as asked, I know he's going to come in with reasoning for not doing so, thus I'll leave it at that.

Vote: Ben

Well shit, now that it doesn't matter what my reasoning is since you painted in that light, do i even bother? Pretty scummy of you.


Fuck it, i'll bother anyways.

REASON: Unlike those of you who spend all of their waking hours behind a computer, i'm RARELY on a computer outside of work. As you were informed yesterday, i was slammed at work for the rest of the day after Dan made his request. When i leave work, i spend 5-6 days a week slaving over cars instead of talking about cars on the internet. I actually DO things. The other days, i hang out with my beautiful fiancee and/or do the errands i've put off from the other days because i simply don't have time to get anything done. Spending MORE time staring at a computer screen is pretty much at the absolute BOTTOM of my list of "things to do when i leave work."

If everyone wants to bring my "Outside of MNMazda life" into play and try to twist it to make me look like scum, then i'll gladly hammer myself out of the game. It's irrelevant, and considering i'm WELL into the top half in terms of activity and participation this game, you're just looking stupid and scummy.


Yet another example of Picklz trying to bring the heat onto me too hard in an effort to cover for himself. Hopefully Dan will give you more "Townie Points" for that little comment.


Obviously, my #1 right now is Picklz. And that was my explanation.


My #2 is still Nate.

He's too sporadic. Makes scummy statements, gets called out, doesn't defend himself. Then magically defends himself 2 days later when he realizes he's about to get hammered. Seems like he's just trying to tightrope the line between too much and too little participation in an effort to keep out of discussion entirely.