Mafia 4 - Night 2, Deadline 10/7 9pm
- Thread starter Workdawg
- Start date
dmention7
Hater
If your suspicion is that Josh and Eddy are scum, and what they want is for Josh to get lynched... why the heck would you not pull the trigger? Do you think we would be worse off with 2 scum who are alive but scummy looking, than with 1 dead scum and 1 scum who appears clean?
If you think Josh and Eddy are scum, then the biggest single piece of evidence you could provide is to lynch and see a Scum swinging from a tree.
I realize that sounds like I'm trying to goad Tom into dropping the hammer, but I can't follow his line of reasoning and arrive at any other course of action than to vote for a lynch of one of the people he suspects as scum. Tom, can you clarify your stance here?
If you think Josh and Eddy are scum, then the biggest single piece of evidence you could provide is to lynch and see a Scum swinging from a tree.
I realize that sounds like I'm trying to goad Tom into dropping the hammer, but I can't follow his line of reasoning and arrive at any other course of action than to vote for a lynch of one of the people he suspects as scum. Tom, can you clarify your stance here?
mndsm
I'M OFFENDED!
My stance is this. Barring any changes in the next couple hours, Josh will be swinging from a tree. I haven't managed to rattle enough cages to get Eddy on a noose, due to poor planning on my part- but Eddy was playing JUST right that I needed as much as possible out of him before I could start tearing into him. It remains to be seen what last ditch efforts will be made by other players. Don't worry, we won't NL day 2. Personally, I wanted to wait as long as possible to corner Eddy, to give him less of a chance to cook up a scheme to get him out of it. If Eddy is scum, he's the brains of the operation. Eddy plays good tactics, showing my hand early would have allowed him to plan around it. Eddy saw me jump on JT d1. He's smart enough to know i'd poke a hole in any plan he had. So my rationale was to wait, let him continue lest he think I'm not paying attention, and call him out when he made a mistake. I figured he'd do enough attacking if he WAS town to set everything up for an easy kill. He sure as hell set up that kill, just not what I expected.
Picklz
SUDO Make me a SAMCH
OMG this shit BLEW UP - I'm still working, don't have time to read/post much at the moment, hopefully will have a chance to read through everything and respond as needed before 9 tonight, as it sits I don't see a huge reason to change my vote from Josh at the moment, I'm not going to say eddy is 100% town at this point though, I think I feel less that way than I did yesterday.
Z
Z-licious
Guest
cuz he's dumb. He was so mad about game 1 that he wouldn't agree with me in the off chance that I was scum. If I were scum his fragile sensibility wouldnt be able to take getting played like a fiddle twice. What you don't know Tom. Is that my inner troll is laughing at the fact that I've got you scared shitless. Now either come up with evidence from my posts to support your half baked theories or work with us to lynch someone today. Without supporting posts your theories are mere paranoia that I've instilled in you since game 1. Town works off of facts, not fear.
dmention7
Hater
Spoken like true town.
W
WhiteSpy9
Guest
Reporting for duty.
mndsm
I'M OFFENDED!
Yeah, THATS not scummy at all. How about instead of me proving you're guilty, you prove you're NOT. I'm not the one attempting to railroad the votes here.
W
WhiteSpy9
Guest
Workdawg
NARWHAL
As the sun sets on MNMazda town, the survivors gather in the town square. After a long debate they decide that Josh looks like a motherfucking scumbag and he is hung up high in the town square
...
but they are wrong.
The remaining townsfolk stare at each other in disbelief... or maybe its that look you get when the Taco Bell comes back to haunt your intestines; who knows.
-----------
Josh, Vanilla Townie, has been lynched during Day 2.
Day two, Final Vote Count
Picklz [0]
Tom [0]
Nate [0]
AJ [0]
Jay [0]
Andy [0]
Eddy [2] - Tom, Josh
Josh [5] - Picklz, AJ, Eddy, Jay, Andy
Not Voting [1] - Nate
--------
The thread is now CLOSED. Please send any night actions to me via PM by 10/7 @ 9pm. Scum may now resume private communications until day 3 begins.
If you would like start day 3 early, I will do so as long as ALL LIVING PLAYERS have sent me a PM requesting the start of the game AND all night actions have been submitted.
...
but they are wrong.
The remaining townsfolk stare at each other in disbelief... or maybe its that look you get when the Taco Bell comes back to haunt your intestines; who knows.
-----------
Josh, Vanilla Townie, has been lynched during Day 2.
Day two, Final Vote Count
Picklz [0]
Tom [0]
Nate [0]
AJ [0]
Jay [0]
Andy [0]
Eddy [2] - Tom, Josh
Josh [5] - Picklz, AJ, Eddy, Jay, Andy
Not Voting [1] - Nate
--------
The thread is now CLOSED. Please send any night actions to me via PM by 10/7 @ 9pm. Scum may now resume private communications until day 3 begins.
If you would like start day 3 early, I will do so as long as ALL LIVING PLAYERS have sent me a PM requesting the start of the game AND all night actions have been submitted.
Last edited:
Workdawg
NARWHAL
The sun rises over MNMazda town and everyone gathers in the town square. A quick headcount reveals the sad, but expected result... someone is missing. After a quick search, Eddy is found face down in his bathroom with a knife sticking out of his chest.
It is now Day 3... you have until 10/14 at 9pm to discuss and vote for a lynch.
With 6 players alive, it is 4 to lynch.
It is now Day 3... you have until 10/14 at 9pm to discuss and vote for a lynch.
With 6 players alive, it is 4 to lynch.
Last edited:
Picklz
SUDO Make me a SAMCH
Well, ain't that interesting...
I'm not really sure what to think about this at this point. A few potential explanations for Eddy's death come to mind right away, as Tom jumped to be the first one to point out (for the second time) Scum could be framing him. They could also just have been scared of Eddy either from Eddy being onto one/both of them, or just from the activity level of Eddy (probably the highest of anyone).
I can't completely overlook the fact that twice in a row Tom was all over trying to get someone who turned out to be Town lynched, it didn't happen, and then they show up dead the next day. It seems like a solid tactic to me, go after someone that others aren't, another townie gets lynched anyway, and night kill the person that makes you look the MOST guilty so people won't really think it was you.
I'm not pushing for a vote or saying that's what happened here but it's a possibility that has crossed my mind and that I can't help but ponder here on D3.
As far as Josh being Town - I need to go back and look at the theories he was throwing out there and how the voting went down to see what might be learned from all that. I think with him having voted for himself and all the drama on the last day there very well may be some clues there.
I'm not really sure what to think about this at this point. A few potential explanations for Eddy's death come to mind right away, as Tom jumped to be the first one to point out (for the second time) Scum could be framing him. They could also just have been scared of Eddy either from Eddy being onto one/both of them, or just from the activity level of Eddy (probably the highest of anyone).
I can't completely overlook the fact that twice in a row Tom was all over trying to get someone who turned out to be Town lynched, it didn't happen, and then they show up dead the next day. It seems like a solid tactic to me, go after someone that others aren't, another townie gets lynched anyway, and night kill the person that makes you look the MOST guilty so people won't really think it was you.
I'm not pushing for a vote or saying that's what happened here but it's a possibility that has crossed my mind and that I can't help but ponder here on D3.
As far as Josh being Town - I need to go back and look at the theories he was throwing out there and how the voting went down to see what might be learned from all that. I think with him having voted for himself and all the drama on the last day there very well may be some clues there.
mndsm
I'M OFFENDED!
Honest to goodness, only reason I'm the first in is I'm putting the kid to bed an just checking all the usual suspects at this time. That and I'm on here ALL the time. Though I'd not blame you for thinking me suspect, I'd think me suspect too. I think I need to revisit my strategy here, because clearly I've been wrong twice, or 3 times if you count my statement of thinking swanny was scum and stating i'd send him if no one else did. I NEED to go back and read some evidence from key people. I have a feeling I've been kicking the wrong rocks the entire time.
AJ
110 HP of FURY!
Unless you are scum, then kicking over any rock is just another piece of your puzzle. I don't have much of a reason to think this isn't your work Tom, it makes sense if it's the plan you and your partner had the whole time. Weird how Nate never voted and how Andy put the kill shot down... I may have been wrong on Swanny but it's looking like I may be right with what I thought was his partners....
W
WhiteSpy9
Guest
wtfbbq...... So Kris wasn't scum or Josh.
This isn't looking good for town.
Nate, are you surprised you are still alive?
This isn't looking good for town.
Nate, are you surprised you are still alive?
Big Nate
Chaos Engineer
No I am not surprised. I am mixing it up with people and making myself look bad.
Plus I was not even kind of on the right track so why would scum off me. They took Eddy out cuz he is good at the game and would eventually figure them out.
Now I need to look back at some of my original thoughts to match people with roles (those that are known and those that are not)
Plus I was not even kind of on the right track so why would scum off me. They took Eddy out cuz he is good at the game and would eventually figure them out.
Now I need to look back at some of my original thoughts to match people with roles (those that are known and those that are not)