Nekko Noir
=^_^=
That's cuz she's more of a pretty, not a hawt. 
I never got the Angelina obsession. I mean Billy Bob and viles of blood, need I say more.Scarlett is another one that's just okay-looking to me but guys just can't get enough. Are they looking at her face or her boobs? She's also got the full lips like Angelina does, which might be another reason for her appeal...?
As for Angelina, she's definitely less appealing now that she's tamed and less mysterious and freaky as she was back then.