Fixed. My grass beating tactics suck.
Mafia 4 - Night 2, Deadline 10/7 9pm
- Thread starter Workdawg
- Start date
Big Nate
Chaos Engineer
Claiming stupidity.....sounds like scum to me.
So that would put AJ and me on the stupid scum team?
Picklz
SUDO Make me a SAMCH
Interesting happenings here chaps!
My feelings on the past hour or so of posting is that Eddy could be onto something with Josh - I do think that he was somewhat justified in some of his early votes, but at the same time many of them don't make a lot of sense and are contradictory, especially this last one. "Trying to get reaction" when 2 people are already voting seems questionable at best.
There IS the possibility also that KrisEddy and Nate are scum together, and with Nate having had 3 votes attempted to draw attention away from Nate onto someone else (Josh).
Need some time to think this over and perform further analysis :haker:
My feelings on the past hour or so of posting is that Eddy could be onto something with Josh - I do think that he was somewhat justified in some of his early votes, but at the same time many of them don't make a lot of sense and are contradictory, especially this last one. "Trying to get reaction" when 2 people are already voting seems questionable at best.
There IS the possibility also that KrisEddy and Nate are scum together, and with Nate having had 3 votes attempted to draw attention away from Nate onto someone else (Josh).
Need some time to think this over and perform further analysis :haker:
Z
Z-licious
Guest
Why would you change what Nate said to this?
"Swanny trying to figure out how to play as this is his first time"
http://www.mnmazda.com/forum/showthread.php?6380-Mafia-game-2.-Now-with-100-more-epic-fail.
Workdawg- 0 votes
AJ- 0 votes
JohnnyT- 0 votes
Picklz- 0 votes
Whitespy9- 0 votes
Zlicious- 0 votes
Big Nate- 0 votes
Niterydr- 0 votes
Dmention7- 0 votes
You clearly played mafia game 2 (barely) so why would you lie and say this is your first game? Grasping at straws for a defense?
"Swanny trying to figure out how to play as this is his first time"
That's a blatant lie. here's proof
http://www.mnmazda.com/forum/showthread.php?6380-Mafia-game-2.-Now-with-100-more-epic-fail.
Workdawg- 0 votes
AJ- 0 votes
JohnnyT- 0 votes
Picklz- 0 votes
Whitespy9- 0 votes
Zlicious- 0 votes
Big Nate- 0 votes
Niterydr- 0 votes
Dmention7- 0 votes
You clearly played mafia game 2 (barely) so why would you lie and say this is your first game? Grasping at straws for a defense?
Z
Z-licious
Guest
Jay, why do you feel the need to keep insinuating that I would be a dangerous scum if I were one? Would like to back that up with posts I have made that sound scummy or are you just planting seeds of dissent towards me? Wouldn't that be paranoia or fear mongering? Back up (your posts) or shut up.
dmention7
Hater
"If you were one" is the key part of that phrase. It means you're a good player at this game, and honestly a good player can do a lot more damage as a scum, than they can good as a townie.
As to your second quote, you posted a wall of quotes from Swanny trying to show how his voting was inconsistent, but which seemed to me that there were some posts missing. Leaving out even a couple of his posts could dramatically change the appearance of his participation in this game, which is why I was reminding myself to go back over his posting history. I think I explained myself and my intentions pretty adequately on that.
AJ
110 HP of FURY!
I'm mixed about Eddy taking over for Kris.. 1) if he's town he's helping us extremely, it's like he's being paid to play this game as he has time to dig and dive into shit most of us don't. For this reason, alone I just can't vote for Eddy this round, too much good info and questions to help us weed out scum. 2) if he's scum, I think we'll figure that out soon enough, and react before it's too late, but again he's playing great.
I'm 99% sure I'm 75% right about 2 of these four being scum: Andy, Swanny, Tom, Nate. Nate has also called me out a couple times about playing dumb, but I guess I don't think I am. I'm putting my thoughts on who I feel is scum out there. That being said I feel todays vote needs to be about the "odds" of hitting a scum memeber this round. If we don't take a shot this round what do we gain? If we hit, great, we'll likely then see who isn't getting the support they had previosuly and maybe narrow that window down to the final memeber... if we miss, then fuck, two of us are gone, but I think things would really clear up for day three voting.
I'm 99% sure I'm 75% right about 2 of these four being scum: Andy, Swanny, Tom, Nate. Nate has also called me out a couple times about playing dumb, but I guess I don't think I am. I'm putting my thoughts on who I feel is scum out there. That being said I feel todays vote needs to be about the "odds" of hitting a scum memeber this round. If we don't take a shot this round what do we gain? If we hit, great, we'll likely then see who isn't getting the support they had previosuly and maybe narrow that window down to the final memeber... if we miss, then fuck, two of us are gone, but I think things would really clear up for day three voting.
I don't think that counts as 1) I barely played and 2) It didn't finish.
The game not finishing doesn't count for me. Also in that game I was townie, and fingered the wrong guy, the doctor. In this game, I am townie again, and so far fingered at least one guy incorrectly (JT).
The other game I figured out that voting got people to react, AKA Dan, but he died because of it. I could really care if the townie and scum gain up on me as long as the scum are figured out in the end, I win dead or alive.
Z
Z-licious
Guest
Seriously, stop. All that would accomplish is paranoia and fear mongering.
Picklz
SUDO Make me a SAMCH
It makes sense either way - you need all players participating which is why it was stated at the beginning of the game when we were asking for signups that you had to be active or you could be mod-killed or replaced, it didn't say you only have to be active if your are scum or town. I do not believe it is any more or less likely KrisEddy is Town or Scum based on Kris being replaced.
AJ
110 HP of FURY!
to keep it fair and not give us the advantage of knowing we can exclude him as scum or not give scum the advantage of not having to kill him off.
Z
Z-licious
Guest
You played in game 2. You know why it failed. Tom replaced an inactive townie (Andy) for being inactive to keep the game going. In doing so he said something that tipped me off that Andy was town. Thanks for trying to incite paranoia though. You wanna build a real case against me?
AJ
110 HP of FURY!
I think we have some good odds that Swanny is one of the scum memebers. In my eyes the odds are greater for that due to his postings fort he game being defensive and not fact finding about others. There isn't anything that keeps me looking away from him, and he's voted to follow others which allow him to place a quick vote for someone who might be town and getting votes. For that reason..
VOTE: JOSH
VOTE: JOSH
Z
Z-licious
Guest
Unvote: Josh
ONLY because he's currently got 3 votes on him and I don't want the day ending early. He's still at the top of my list and I will gladly swing that hammer down if nothing changes between now and the deadline.
ONLY because he's currently got 3 votes on him and I don't want the day ending early. He's still at the top of my list and I will gladly swing that hammer down if nothing changes between now and the deadline.
AJ
110 HP of FURY!
Lynch or no lynch, that's my vote for day two and it's not changing. My other vote was likely going to lean twoard Andy or Nate over Tom at this point, but I just think Josh has better offs of being one of the scum members with his posting. And unless I've missed it, Andy has never went after Josh, which would lead me to belive they could be playing to keep apart and if we get Josh, I'm likely hitting up Andy with Day 3 vote if I'm not killed off.